1119 replies to this topic

[TheRandomGuy]

7/10. Your rides could be a little more interesting but have great track work nonetheless.

[-=Zach=-]

9.5/10. Your creations have flawless shaping. And although they have bad speed loss, they are all still amazing and realistic.

[Connector1o1]

9/10 You always amaze me with what you build. Evan though your coasters are small, they look fantastic!

[Gvus]

8/10 I have not seen a lot from you yet, but from what I have seen you are a good builder, but build a bit unrealistic coasters.

[Yannick]

8.9/10
Your shaping is very good and on your new coaster you're doing very good with speed

[JayketheKid]

7.5 coasters are pretty good from what I have seen. I haven't seen much though

[Jumpge]

I haven't really seen too much building from you yet... but from what I have seen, your shaping seems fairly good. I really don't know what that translates to in numbers... sorry.

[CartRacer56]

9.5/10 shaping is superb speed is very realistic and the .5 deduction is the shaking in the tubes on Complexity

[JayketheKid]

6/10 ambitious projects, but shaping is often bad and you never finish any rides that I have seen on this site

[-=Zach=-]

8.5
You have a very unique style that I quite like.

[SCM]

9/10
You have really awesome shaping skills and you're starting to become one of my favorite builders!

[IonZer0]

8/10
You make some really great creations. Your track work is excellent. My only complaint is that you seem to have a bit of trouble transitioning from large scale elements to elements later on in a layout, like the last few elements on Ningen. I felt that it started as a beast, lost a lot of speed (not your fault), and ended like a cute bunny hopping back to the station. If you take a look at St33l's Steel Force, then you can see how he kept the elements to scale, even though he ended up with plenty of speed left over going into the brake run.

[Yannick]

7.5/10
Your Coasters have a good start but you have to finish them.

[REXENK]

7/10 You definetly had some different building styles to begin with, (creativity) but now you have learned a lot and have used knowledge in building..you can't go wrong when you have knowledge and creativity..still have a lot to learn though(we all do) jabberwocky is a good example of your improvement in "knowledge building" you are bound to be a great builder someday.

[frank]

9/10

Only one roller coaster but shaping is great.

[dylpickled]

6.5/10. you have lots of pieces, but I feel you don't use them efficiently. also, you've only made big coasters. I feel you should start smaller and take your time with shaping.

[CartRacer56]

7/10 Your builds have nice shaping and keep speed relatively well, but haven't seen enough of you to give a more accurate number

[Spaghetti]

For CartRacer... Hmmmm, I would say a 6.25 out of 10. To improve, I would stick with small projects and work on shaping, other than that, you are a very solid builder.

 

Go ahead, roast me. I've never completed something, so I would really like an honest rating and some advice to improve.

[KirbyCoast]

For sphagooter I would say 6.5/10. Most of the builds you've made so far have been great, but you might want to make some smaller projects so that you can finish them (I think you will finish your woodie though). Basically the same thing you said to Cartracer.

Edited by KirbyCoast, 24 June 2016 - 03:36 PM.

[CW5X]

I'm gonna say a 7/10 but certainly improving all the time. Your new coaster seems to be coming together nicely and you're learning about adapting your rides to make them work too.